NYCHA’s Related Redevelopment Dinds Unlikely DSA Allies


Fulton and Elliott Chelsea Houses tenants fighting private redevelopment got the cold shoulder from the DSA.
Support is cropping up on unlikely ends of the political spectrum for the Permanent Affordability Commitment Together program, which taps private developers to build on NYCHA campuses, converting the city’s aging Section 9 public housing to a project-based Section 8 model while adding market-rate units to subsidize redevelopment.
The Mamdani administration made it clear early on that the mayor and Deputy Mayor Leila Bozorg see a role for developers in addressing affordability issues.
Now the NYC-DSA and one of its other high-profile exports, Mayor’s Office to Protect Tenants head Cea Weaver, fell in line when the Fulton and Elliott-Chelsea PACT debate reached a fever pitch last weekend.
The New York City DSA voted down a resolution, 178 in favor and 230 against, to formally oppose the administration’s plan to work with Related and Essence on the NYCHA redevelopment. Every other resolution before the local DSA chapter, including a formal call for Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez to run for president in 2028, was approved at the convention.
Beforehand, Weaver spelled out on X her rationale for backing PACT.
“NYCHA residents deserve high-quality, permanently affordable, beautiful, PUBLIC housing,” she said in a Nov. 14 post. “Not going to leave any dollars on the table or any stones unturned in our effort to make that happen.”
The semantics rankled some commenters from the tenant organizing circles Weaver ran in before securing a City Hall role, who argued that project-based Section 8 isn’t public housing if Related owns it, at least not by the same standards as the current NYCHA Section 9 model.
Weaver’s stance garnered praise from other sides, including YIMBY boosters and Jay Martin, former NYAA spokesperson, now a public relations consultant for real estate and landlord clients. Abundance New York co-founder Ryder Kessler took to X following the DSA vote against the anti-PACT resolution, lamenting that it even got as much support as it did.
In the lead-up to the vote, Weaver sought to illustrate why she stood on the side of PACT redevelopment at Fulton and Elliott-Chelsea Houses, telling Gothamist that “keeping our public housing in disrepair as it is today is not acceptable to me given my socialist values.”
What we’re thinking about: Is loyalty to Mamdani the reason DSA may be pulling punches by not opposing the Related redevelopment of NYCHA housing? Or are developers and Democratic socialists finding common cause around the PACT program? Let me know at ben.miller@therealdeal.com.
A thing we’ve learned: New York City may be known around the world as “The Big Apple,” but the first apple trees originated in Central Asia. The wild apple tree that is the primary ancestor of domesticated apple varieties still grows in Kazakhstan. The name of the country’s largest city and former capital, Almaty, translates to “Place of Apples.”
Elsewhere…
— Mayor Mamdani and NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced today that the city will disband the Strategic Response Group policing unit, which was tasked with both counterterrorism and crowd control at protests. Some see the move as the mayor delivering a campaign promise by shifting protest response to a new civilian Community Dialogue and De-Escalation Division, while others argue that adding a Patrol Support Division and armed First Amendment Support Team are more of a rebranding effort, Gothamist reported.
— Winning the New York City affordable housing lottery is an uphill battle, giving applicants a one in 510 chance to nab a unit on Housing Connect, according to The City Reporter’s review of public data over a two-year span. Lower-income households face harder odds of winning, due to greater demand and less inventory, as most advertised lottery apartments are only available to middle-income applicants.
— State Sen. Liz Kreuger seems less interested in the role of housing chair for her legislative body, expressing to City & State that she is open to dividing her role atop the Finance Committee in half as a co-chair or even no committee responsibilities at all. State Sen. Julia Salazar, meanwhile, is still angling to lead the Housing Committee.
Closing time
Residential: The most expensive residential sale recorded Monday was $4.4 million for 420 East 75th Street, unit 4. The new construction condo in Lenox Hills is 2,400 square feet. The Corcoran Group’s Nicholas Hovsepian, Caitlin Williams, Leslie Marshall and Stephanie Wilberding had the listing.
Commercial: The most expensive commercial transaction recorded was $22.4 million for 1440 Story Avenue. The two-story building is over 80,000 square feet. NYC School Construction Authority is listed as the buyer, per records.
New to the Market: The highest price for a residential property hitting the market is $16.5 million for 128 East 74th Street. The Lenox Hill townhome is 6,800 square feet. Serhant’s Melissa Post and Ryan Serhant have the listing.
— Joseph Jungermann



