Market

Mamdani Uses False Claims Act to Sue Landlord Barry Singer


Mayor Zohran Mamdani has unveiled a new tool in his arsenal to go after so-called “low-road” landlords.

Building owners are now subject to a new strain of lawsuits after City Hall sued Barry Singer under the False Claims Act, seeking more than $10 million in damages and penalties.

Mamdani pledged in his campaign to crack down on landlord neglect across the five boroughs. That’s now being realized in his administration’s housing plan. The city’s law department on Tuesday took a novel approach to that end, pursuing an untested legal route to hold Singer liable for violations that racked up more than $1 million in fines and emergency repairs across 11 apartment buildings in the Bronx and Brooklyn, where conditions range from a facade with “potential to collapse” to water damage, along with missing roof sections and windows.

Singer’s portfolio had nearly 2,900 open HPD violations when he earned the top spot on the Public Advocate’s annual “worst landlord list” in 2024, ranking third with 15 buildings on the watchlist last year. His reputation stretches back to 2001, when The New York Post reported on his attempts to harass tenants and noted more than 2,000 violations at five Harlem buildings he owned and 220 at one in the Bronx.

City and state governments have historically utilized the False Claims Act to recover assets lost to fraud and secure triple damages plus civil penalties for instances of knowing misconduct. 

Health care providers improperly billing the state or government contractors falsifying invoices were typical targets of suits under the statute until Aaron Carr, founder of watchdog group Housing Rights Initiative, worked with the city to leverage it against noncompliant owners.

The city’s complaint alleges that Singer, along with another owner, Daniel Caller, and entities associated with their properties, evaded payments they owe the city for emergency repairs, pest control and judgments resulting from housing code violations. 

The lawsuit asks the court to impose penalties of $1,000 per day for each violation of the Nuisance Abatement Law, alleging defendants are liable for damages and penalties of up to $28,619 per violation under the False Claims Act. 

The outcome of the first-of-its-kind case in Bronx County Supreme Court could dictate whether city lawyers apply the strategy against a broader swath of landlords. Dina Levy, commissioner of the city’s Department of Housing Preservation and Development, spoke to TRD about the administration’s new legal approach, and what it means for tenants and landlords going forward.

The interview has been condensed and edited for clarity.

What is the potential scope of these False Claims Act lawsuits? What would stop the city from bringing claims against everyone on the public advocate’s worst landlord list?

To be perfectly frank, this is untested. It’s the first time we’ve tried this and it’s super innovative. If successful, it becomes a powerful new tool, not just for Barry Singer, who has been around for decades, but for other chronically bad landlords who accrue these kinds of debts, don’t address them and don’t bring buildings into compliance.

It’s not whether past attempts were successful or unsuccessful. I think it’s complicated. Property rights are held very dear in the Constitution, and we do have this small but very formidable group of chronically bad landlords who have been gaming the system for years, in some cases for decades. What the mayor’s saying, and I think we agree, is that we need to open avenues to new tools. What’s strategic here is layering these enforcement actions together, bringing in partners in law enforcement. 

Those that have criminal jurisdiction, like the Attorney General’s office and the District Attorney’s office, are also open to collaborating to put an end to this cycle of landlords who have made a business model out of sucking every dollar from their building and leaving tenants living in unacceptable conditions. We are going to start to layer these things together until we either force full compliance, or frankly a change in ownership.

Is the damages amount in this case so high that the sale of the portfolio would be necessary?

The higher the penalties, the more leverage we have. If this is successful and we win this case, it is a super lien, in that it takes priority over the mortgage. If you were to try to sell the buildings or if you went into foreclosure, you would not be able to deal with that without addressing this lien. The higher the lien, the more challenging it is to ignore it, and the more leverage it gives the city to really control what happens to these buildings.

What has HPD’s experience been with violations piling up? Do you see litigation as the real incentive for landlords to comply, or do violations have power to change behavior?

I think it’s both. We have an open case right now in HPD’s own litigation unit with Barry Singer, which we are pursuing simultaneously, including a criminal contempt motion. Legal avenues are certainly an important part of our enforcement strategy. 

There are other strategies that we are using now, like doing a lot of work to make sure that lenders are using the tools at their disposal to hold these landlords accountable. It is important that we are pushing the bounds, thinking of enforcement in new ways. 

What we’re thinking about: Do you think that the city will succeed in securing damages under this statute? Let me know at ben.miller@therealdeal.com.

A thing we’ve learned: Life Magazine began publishing on Nov. 18, 1883, as a humor and general interest publication. A change in ownership prompted the shift to a photojournalism weekly in 1936, which was recently revived again after two decades lying dormant by Bedford Media, a company owned by Karlie Kloss and Joshua Kushner.

Elsewhere…

— Gov. Kathy Hochul is still exploring the prospect of reforming the state’s Scaffold Law, even amid calls for increased construction safety following the collapse of a Flatbush building into an adjacent job site last week, City & State reported.

— New York may soon face a first-ever statewide resource deficiency, with electricity supply projections insufficient to reliably meet demand starting in 2033, according to a New York Independent System Operator study. New York City is projected to fall 400 megawatts short in 2032.

— The Mamdani administration plans to begin demolishing a facility on Rikers Island next year, starting with a nearly century-old jail and medical facility known as North Infirmary Command in its broader blueprint to shutter the notorious jail complex, according to The City Reporter.

Closing time

Residential: The most expensive residential sale recorded Wednesday was $27.8 million for a 7691-square-foot, sponsor-sale condominium at The Flatiron Building, 175 Fifth Avenue. Corcoran Sunshine had the listing. 

Commercial: The most expensive commercial transaction recorded was $41 million for eight pre-war, four-story walkup rental apartments at 21-14, 24, 32, 36, 44, 52, 58, 66 Crescent Street in Astoria. Combined, there are 192 units. The properties are tied to Peter Papamichael of The Vorea Group and were sold to the entity Crescent Street I LLC.

New to the Market: The highest price for a residential property hitting the market is $7 million for a co-op at 980 Fifth Avenue on the Upper East Side. Christine Miller Martin with Compass has the listing. 

Breaking Ground: The largest new building permit filed was for a proposed 34,947-square-foot, 49-unit project at 453 Third Avenue in Gowanus. Timothy Rote with Trend New York Architecture filed the permit on behalf of developer Abraham Lipschitz.

— Matthew Elo




Source link

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *