Flushing Developer, Owners Sue Over 120-Year-Old Deed Rule

In 1906, the developers of a Flushing subdivision barred apartment buildings on a stretch of land in the leafy suburban neighborhood. A century later, a developer got approval from the city to build one.
Now, Andrew Esposito’s Apex Development is going to federal court to throw the deed restrictions out, alleging they violate the Fair Housing Act. But Flushing homeowners are suing back, using the deed restrictions to try to block the 10-story building.
The proposed mixed-use building at 158-06 Northern Boulevard would include 76 apartments, 19 of them affordable. Apex secured a rezoning for the project in October. The homeowners association, founded in 1964 specifically to enforce the covenants, says it tried unsuccessfully to negotiate with Apex during the rezoning process.
They say the development runs afoul of the Rickert-Finlay Covenants, 28 private deed restrictions established in 1906 and incorporated into property deeds beginning in 1920. The restrictions were intended to preserve the neighborhood’s then-park-like atmosphere (Northern Boulevard is now a multilane commercial thoroughfare).
One provision prohibits apartment buildings except in a specifically designated section of the subdivision. The development site falls outside that area. Raymond and Barbara Ciccolilli live in a single-family home right next to the proposed project. They are suing Apex in state court, along with the Broadway-Flushing Homeowners’ Association.
Apex, however, argues that the restrictions are relics of a different era, when the area was a suburban enclave of stables and single-family homes. The property has been used for commercial purposes for decades, including as a restaurant and dialysis center, according to the developer’s complaint.
Apex argues that enforcing the covenants would violate the federal Fair Housing Act because a prohibition on multifamily housing disproportionately excludes minority and lower-income renters, and decades of change in the neighborhood have rendered the restrictions obsolete.
The project is on hold as the legal fights play out.
“We take community relations very seriously and we remain willing to find an amicable solution, but we believe housing is a critical necessity right now, and we’re not going to be discouraged by 120-year-old restrictive covenants,” Esposito said.
A lawyer for the homeowners association declined to comment.
Read more
City Council approves controversial Brooklyn rezoning at Arrow Linen site
Trump appointees hamstring HUD’s fair housing enforcement



