Landlords Receive Second Change After DHCR Rule 40 Change

A couple of sentences in an obscure government document may have saved landlords hundreds of millions of dollars.
The form, known as Fact Sheet 40, provides guidance to landlords on preferential rents, which are rents set below the legal limit for rent-regulated units.
In 2019, the state’s Division of House and Community Renewal removed language that distinguished between preferential rents, which set a unit’s rent at an amount lower than can be legally, and rent concessions, which are temporary agreements granting tenants rent-free months.
At the same time, the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act in 2019, which expressly prohibited owners from hiking rents on tenants previously paying preferential rents.
Taken together, the HSTPA and the update to Fact Sheet 40 appeared to give tenants — and opportunistic attorneys and housing activists — free rein to go after landlords that had offered rent concessions for one reason or another since 2019.
Unsurprisingly, during the pandemic, landlords had a multitude of reasons to offer rent concessions. But they also offered them to compensate for construction-related noise or to help get tenants in the door during slow market periods.
Those concessions have come under fire in recent months. At least 21 lawsuits have been filed involving more than 24 properties, 12,000 units and $1 billion in tax credits that property owners received as part of their participation in the 421-a program, according to data compiled by law firm Adler & Stachenfeld. Big-name landlords facing lawsuits include Two Trees, Josh Gotlib’s Black Spruce Management and Blackstone.
But this month, DHCR again updated its fact sheet to now re-clarify that rent concessions can be distinct from preferential rents. The agency “continues to recognize that there are distinctions between rent concessions and preferential rents,” and its 2019 modification “was not intended to indicate the contrary,” the fact sheet now states.
“Due to recent confusion, DHCR’s guidance clarifies that the agency continues to recognize rent concessions may be lawful under certain legal circumstances,” a spokesperson for the agency said in a statement. “Each case is fact-specific, however, and, as always, DHCR will not pre-judge any particular case as to whether a concession is lawful or not.”
Landlord attorneys hailed the update as a potential life raft, while noting that the legal ramifications will still need to be sorted out in court.
“It gives us much better leverage,” said Kucker Marino Winiarsky & Bittens partner Nativ Winiarsky. “Before this fact sheet was changed it was so easy to say anytime there’s a rent concession, it’s automatically an overcharge.”
Belkin Burden Goldman partner Matthew Brett, who has represented landlords in a number of 421-a rent concession cases that have reached the state’s appellate court, said the update was a “significant development.”
“The agency has now said plainly that it continues to recognize a distinction between rent concessions and preferential rents, and that its 2019 revision was never intended to suggest otherwise,” he said in a statement. “Whether a concession is a preferential rent depends on the specific facts and circumstances when the lease was signed, such as conditions at the building, what was happening with occupancy, and how long the concession lasted.”
Brett noted that many cases filed in the wake of a decision known as Grey, which appeared to confirm the equivalence of rent concessions and preferential rent, may struggle to move forward because they “assumed that every post-HSTPA concession is automatically a preferential rent, and they contain no specific allegations about the circumstances of the concessions.”
Nearly all of these lawsuits have been filed by Newman Ferrara partner Roger Sachar. In one recent suit that claimed AvalonBay overcharged Downtown Brooklyn tenants by at least $40 million, Sachar cited Grey and wrote that “the law is clear that rent concessions cannot be used to circumvent HSTPA’s preferential rent bar.”
The law has now, seemingly, become less clear. (Sachar did not respond to a request for comment.)
Attorneys still cautioned that the change does not mean wholesale victory for these cases, and it remains to be seen how the courts will interpret the changes, which can involve the close-reading of every word. (Winiarsky, for example, said that the use of the word “continues” likely bodes well for asking the courts to reconsider decisions in some of the recent, seemingly decisive cases like Grey.)
Most importantly, landlords will at least now have a chance to argue their case, according to Brett.
“There is no one-size-fits-all rule,” he said.
Read more
Another fine mess: Rent concessions blow up on builders
NY Dirt: The making of a real estate villain
Tenants predict wins in 421a overcharge suits. Landlords beg to differ



