Housing Solutions for New York Governor Kathy Hochul in 2027

With momentum from her 20-point election victory, Gov. Kathy Hochul is expected to pursue a robust housing agenda next year. What should she do?
Hochul’s Housing Compact crashed and burned in 2023 but she has made important gains since. In 2024 she lifted New York City’s density cap, extended the construction deadline for the expired 421a, created a replacement for 421a called 485x and enacted the wildly successful 467m office-to-residential conversion program.
This year she moved the ball down the field again by exempting some housing development from New York’s overwrought, lawsuit-triggering environmental review.
But more reform is needed to alleviate the shortage of homes. Here are three ways the governor can do that.
Fix 485x. The tax break for multifamily development in New York City has worked well for projects up to 99 units and terribly for those with 100 or more. At that threshold, a wage floor for construction workers and building service staff kicks in, and the affordability minimum jumps to 1 in 4 apartments instead of 1 in 5.
As if that weren’t enough, the filing fee rises to $5,000 from $4,000 per unit, meaning the 100th unit adds $100,000 in fees. And no one knows how severely violators of these provisions would be punished, so developers don’t risk going above 99. On large sites, some build back-to-back 99-unit projects — even 10 in a row.
The politics of fixing 485x are hard because governors and lawmakers typically kowtow to the labor groups who advocated for the wage floor and continue to defend it. Also, progressive legislators don’t like to reduce affordability percentages.
But arguments for reform are easy. The city can’t reach Mamdani’s goal of 700,000 units by building 99 at a time. The unions don’t get prevailing wage and progressives don’t get 25 percent affordability on 485x projects that don’t happen. At the very least, lawmakers should implement a sliding scale that doesn’t make projects less profitable as they get larger, and define a predictable enforcement regime.
Hochul is aiming to kill another sacred cow of construction unions, Labor Law 240, which inflates their members’ settlements for gravity-related injuries. If she can’t amend both the “scaffold law” and 485x, perhaps she will make the unions choose between them, guaranteeing herself at least one victory.
Fill vacant units. Political pressure to increase the supply of low-rent housing has never been greater. Few people still believe tenant activists’ conspiracy theory that thousands of landlords are “warehousing” rent-stabilized units as a hostage-taking strategy, or that units can be renovated for only $30,000 after long tenancies.
Unfortunately, one of those people is Assembly housing chair Linda Rosenthal. But committee chairs can be overcome when governors or fellow legislators demand action.
With the official count at 57,000 vacancies, Hochul must solve this problem in 2027. Mayor Zohran Mamdani would be a powerful messenger for reform, although I suspect he prefers a government-funding solution rather than raising the $30,000 limit for Individual Apartment Improvements, which comes with a rent increase.
As with 485x, the case for reform is simple: No one benefits from freezing the rent of an apartment that remains vacant. Renovation helps everyone: owners, lenders, contractors, architects, engineers, tradespeople and most of all the tenants who move in.
I’d love to see the city’s Department of Design and Construction offer to bring any apartment up to code for $30,000, but the agency only does public projects.
More plausible is a solution modeled on the J-51 property tax break just passed by the state and city, with a real-world cost schedule so landlords are not hamstrung by low spending caps or accused of running up the bill.
Reform property taxes. If Mamdani finishes his second year with no progress on property taxes, it will become part of the unkept-promises list that attaches to every mayor like a barnacle.
The state’s highest court has already ordered the city to make taxes fairer for homeowners (who don’t all pay the same percentage of their home’s value) and rental buildings (which are overtaxed if they lack an abatement). Politically, the more palatable path is to ask Albany to act.
Regardless, Mamdani will have to enact or endorse a proposal. Fortunately, no mayor has ever been better positioned to redistribute the tax levy, which would raise taxes on valuable homes currently being undercharged. Townhouses in gentrified neighborhoods, for example. Or ritzy co-ops whose taxes are based in part on rent-stabilized comps, which is absurd.
Wealthy homeowners are not Mamdani’s base; his voters are renters whose buildings would benefit from tax reform. Besides, he and his ally Hochul can say the court ordered reform, which will be revenue-neutral.
The premise must be that similar properties pay the same percentage of their market values. That’s easy to understand and hard to dispute.
Read more
Landlord does the math on his vacant apartment
How 485x is distorting development and raising rents
High court revives lawsuit calling NYC property taxes unconstitutional



