Last Seen in 1929: Have Silver Chub Returned?

The Silver Chub (Macrhybopsis storeriana) is a medium-sized, relatively nondescript minnow that, in New York, has only been collected from the watersheds of Lake Erie and Lake Ontario.
This species was last seen during surveys of the Lake Erie watershed in 1929 and has long been thought to be extirpated from the state, largely due to extensive pollution in the lake and its tributaries. Silver chubs are mainly restricted to large, often silty rivers and are sometimes found near the mouths of small streams.
There have been indications, however, that the species may have returned to areas where it was historically found.
In 2022, a New York angler caught an individual in Cattaraugus Creek that was possibly a Silver Chub. Unfortunately, the specimen was not retained, and photographs were not 100% conclusive.
In 2024, the NY State Museum fish collection received a specimen collected by NYS Department of Environmental Conservation personnel, also from Cattaraugus Creek, that resembles a Silver Chub in many respects.
This specimen, however, appears to be atypical in some ways, again leading to some uncertainty in its identification.
NYSM fish collection scientists are engaging in fieldwork in Western New York for the summer of 2025 in the hopes that additional specimens can be located and genetic samples taken for more conclusive identifications.
Silver chub photo provided by the New York State Museum.
Source link