The Subway in Paint: New York in the 1930s


During the 1920s, Americans identified self-worth with wealth and success. The nation’s decisive participation in World War I and the era of prosperity that followed instilled an outlook of positive anticipation.
That perspective changed dramatically when the economic collapse began to manifest itself after the stock market crash of October 29, 1929.
During the early 1930s unemployment rocketed, leaving many Americans destitute, whilst inaction of the federal government turned joblessness into a stigma. As the crisis deepened, confidence sank to general malaise. Some commentators described this crash in terms of the “Fall.” The City upon a Hill dream turned into a nightmare.
For a decade, the Great Depression defined life in the United States. President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal was a step towards healing some of the internal damage, but the crisis left deep scars. Never before had similar disillusionment engulfed the nation.
Crossroads
On arrival in New York City during the late nineteenth century, most newcomers from Eastern Europe settled in the Lower East Side. As immigrant communities tended to segregate into ethnic neighborhoods, newspapers, signboards, plays, and political debate were all published, displayed, or conducted in Yiddish. The overcrowded district turned into a nucleus of “Yiddishkeit.”
Having escaped persecution, many Eastern European Jews overcame the toll of emigration and made their way up during the economic boom of the 1920s, but experiences of persecution and dislocation remained etched in the collective memory.

Well into the 1930s, many of them (women more so than men) were unwilling to consider naturalization; Yiddish stayed the first language. Despite reservations, the process of assimilation into the American mainstream was ongoing and numbers of settlers could celebrate ascending the social ladder “from rags to riches.”
The Depression brought renewed pain. The Wall Street crash created panic both in the well-established German-Jewish community and in that of the more recently settled East European section.
The Bank of United States at Delancey Street, Manhattan, founded in 1913 by Joseph Marcus, a Jewish immigrant from the German state of Brandenburg, collapsed in December 1930. At the time, the bank held the savings of countless New York Jews. Its closure left thousands of families and many businesses devastated.
With the downturn, Jewish youngsters who had grown up in the 1920s found themselves at a crossroads between the once vibrant migrant world of their parents and a harsh new reality. The land of opportunity was transformed into a fractured nation of reduced possibilities, growing anti-Semitism, and socio-political turmoil.
The future looked bleak. In the turmoil, artists reinterpreted their creative mission. Sensitive to the suffering of fellow citizens, urban loneliness and social disconnect became common themes in literature and art.
Bernard Gussow
Born on January 2, 1881, in Minsk (then part of the Russian Empire; now Belarus), Bernard Gussow was the son of a rabbi. The family fled persecution and settled in New York City.
By 1900 Bernard had made his way to the Lower East Side. He studied at New York’s City College and trained at both the Art Students League and the National Academy of Design.
In 1902/3 he was in Paris, studying at the École des Beaux-Arts. He shared a Montparnasse studio with the Russian-born American painter Charles Ezekiel Polowetski. Sculptor Jacob Epstein, born on the Lower East Side into a Jewish family of Polish immigrants, also used its facilities.
Back in Manhattan, Gussow was supported by the Educational Alliance. Located at 197 East Broadway, the organization used the property as a settlement house for Eastern European Jews. It was here that Bernard displayed his first paintings.
In the early 1920s, Manhattan’s art world was roaring. Painters were in search of an American style away from the stifling rules of academic tradition. Modernism was the buzz word; urban life the main source of inspiration. Manhattan became the epicenter of American modern art.

The vanguard marched forward. Gussow was co-founder of the Modern Artists in America group in 1922 and took part in its first show at the Joseph Brummer Galleries at East 57th Street.
By the mid-1930s the socio-economic situation had deteriorated and the artistic infrastructure collapsed. Numerous efforts were made nationwide to support suffering artists. The intention of such ventures was laudable, but their effect minimal.
At the time of President Roosevelt’s inauguration in 1933, some 10,000 artists struggled to survive.
In this dark climate, Gussow’s creative outlook changed as he moved attention from abstract compositions to cityscapes. He specifically focused on the subway, depicting New Yorkers amid the grinding machinery of urban transit. During the 1930s he created a series of haunting metro paintings in which he recorded the city in motion.
With images of pushing crowds, Gussow conveyed the feel of subway corridors and platforms. Looking at his paintings, one can almost feel the press of bodies packed onto a late afternoon train.
He portrayed commuters as impersonal beings. They are identical; their faces indistinct; their eyes without expression. The underground prevents interaction. The individual functions merely as something in which he/she ceases to be a personality.

The artist’s subway scenes express isolation and alienation; the individual lost in a horde of people. Gussow’s use of muted colors deepened that sense of anonymity. His paintings captured the gloom of the 1930s.
Joseph Solman
In 1935, Joseph Solman and Mark Rothko co-founded “The Ten,” a group of mostly Jewish painters who exhibited in 1938 under the name of “Whitney Dissenters” at the Mercury Galleries at East 8th Street, near the Whitney Museum of American Art (opened in 1931).
Many of these artists would achieve global attention, but in those early days they positioned themselves as outcasts.
Born on January 25, 1909, in Vitebsk (Belarus, then part of the Russian Empire), Salman arrived with his Jewish parents in New York City in 1912. The family settled in Jamaica, Long Island. His graphic talent was clear from an early age.
After attending high school, he went straight on to Manhattan’s National Academy of Design, located at the time in the American Fine Arts building at 215 West 57th Street.
Despite his formal training, Solman would claim that he learned his trade by sketching people traveling on trains. He once described the underground as the greatest “art studio of all time.” Having to earn a living to pursue his creative calling, he documented dozens of passengers as he commuted to and from Belmont Park racetrack where he was employed as a betting clerk.

Traveling with pencil at hand, using betting slips as sketch paper, he produced a series of what later became known as his “Subway Gouaches.” Solman used minimalist means to depict random passengers engrossed in their private world whilst stuck on a public train.
His commuters have a stare of disinterest or remoteness, lost in thought or preoccupied with their newspaper, while suffering the discomfort of mass transport.
Solman’s subway images are a metaphor for the metropolis: crowded, noisy, hasty, but isolated and self-contained at the same time. His driving concern was to capture everyday figures in their urban settings. A creator of sensitive gouache portraits, some critics affectionately labeled him a “pari-mutuel Picasso.”
Mark Rothko
Mark Rothko was born Markus Yakovlevich Rothkowitz on September 25, 1903, in Daugavpils, Latvia (then part of the Russian Empire). His father Jacob was a left-wing pharmacist who provided his children with a secular upbringing. When he decided to re-engage with Judaism, he sent Mark to a Jewish primary school while his elder siblings remained within the public system.
In an environment where authorities held Jews accountable for the troubles that had befallen the country, family life was plagued by fear. When Rothko’s elder brothers were about to be drafted into the Imperial Russian Army, Jacob took them to the United States.
Mark, his mother and sister followed them later, arriving at Ellis Island in late 1913. They joined other family members in Portland, Oregon. Jacob died a few months later, leaving the family without support and in dire poverty.
Growing up in Oregon shaped Mark’s political and anti-religious views. Portland was a center of radicalism, and he attended meetings of the Workers of the World (IWW). Having received a scholarship to Yale in 1922, he abhorred its elitist atmosphere. At the end of his sophomore year, Rothko dropped out. Forty-six years later Yale would award him with an honorary degree.
By the autumn of 1923 Rothko was working in Manhattan’s garment district. Keen to become an artist, he enrolled at Parsons School of Design in Greenwich Village, a private college with a tradition of creative autonomy (Edward Hopper had been a student at the college), which suited his independent character. He would always despise labels in art.
In 1928 he made his career debut, showing paintings at the Opportunity Gallery on 56th Street, a name that reflected growing hardship for young artists. A subsidized small venue, the Gallery provided a platform for painters to connect with audiences and collectors.
During in the late 1920s and early 1930s it hosted monthly exhibitions for emerging artists to display their paintings or sculptures.

Working from a studio on 53rd Street, young Rothko’s depictions of 1930s New York were inspired by the subway. Although he never set out to create a “series” of such paintings, these images were a recurring theme in his early work.
The station platform is presented as a bare space where people stand close, not as a collective but cut off from one another, isolated, as if trapped in their solitary inner worlds.
In a railway environment associated with noise and speed, Rothko depicted skinny and faceless figures – like sculptures taken out of Alberto Giacometti’s Swiss studio – that seem immobilized and frozen in their steps.
While there is no record of Giacometti and Rothko ever meeting, critics have pointed at their common legacies of exploring a fragile human condition. These pictures captured the loneliness of New York City during the Depression.
Rothko’s expressionistic style set him aside from Depression-era realist painters. Realism never was his mission. He explored means of visualizing the emotional feel of the urban landscape. Although politically engaged, he refused to sacrifice artistic integrity to message.
He defended the necessity of art’s independence and the artist’s duty to search for new forms.
Brushed Aside
As critics have concentrated primarily on the rise of Abstract Expressionism and other non-objective styles, the figurative work of these subway artists has been overlooked (a fate they shared with artists of the realist or “American Scene” movement).
When Bussow died in 1957 in his red-brick apartment at 855 West End Avenue, his work had long been ignored. Solman passed in 2008 at his home on 10th Street, West Village, eight months short of his 100th birthday. He had suffered similar neglect.
Rothko may today be celebrated as a pioneer of “Color Field” painting (color as the primary subject of a work), but the important stage of figural representation in his career has been underrated.
During the 1930s, New York City’s ageing transport system symbolized the wider challenges that the metropolis faced in supporting and renewing its infrastructure.
The subway was a crucial means of transit, but the Depression affected its development. Expansion and improvement plans were postponed or stalled due to soaring costs. There was a stark psychological dimension too.
Because of its association with confinement, “underground” is a metaphor for fear and anxiety. In art and literature, it evokes the dread of the hidden, the unknown, the subterranean – and ultimately: death.
It is significant that three second generation Russian-Jewish immigrant painters developed the subway theme during a time of crisis. Memories of exclusion and persecution that had haunted their parents seemed to return, manifesting itself as “secondary traumatization.”
Intergenerational trauma is the transmission of emotional and physiological distress from one generation to the next. People who have survived adverse ordeals or disasters may pass on the effects of mental suffering to descendants who had not experienced the original events. Bernard Bussow, Joseph Solman, and Mark Rothko post their own “Notes from Underground.”
Read More About New York Art History
Illustrations, from above: Mark Rothko, Subway (untitled), ca. 1937 (National Gallery of Art); Bernard Gussow, Grand Central Station, 1930s (private owner); Bernard Gussow, Crowded Subway Car, 1930s (private owner); a poster for the “Whitney Dissenters” exhibition by The Ten at the Mercury Galleries, November 1938; Joseph Solman, “Subway Rider,” one of three gouaches on newsprint paper; and Mark Rothko, “Entrance to Subway,” 1938.
Source link



