MovieMovies

What We Talk About When We Talk About James Bond…


You get your James Bond fan card after the first time you watch Goldfinger and sniff witheringly, ​“It’s not as good as From Russia with Love.” You get your extra star, or maybe Double‑O status, when you grouse about whomever is up for being cast in the new film. And when the role is cast, the actor is too goofy, too boring, too blonde, too vanilla, too trained, not vanilla enough, not handsome enough, not zany enough. 

James Bond casting for the fan is very much like Goldilocks but if she were deciding on who should next embody the escapist fantasies of the once-virile, now-frail British Empire. Or you could say it’s like that somewhat apocryphal Supreme Court obscenity ruling from 1964, in which Justice Potter Stewart said, talking about pornography, ​“I know it when I see it.” 

Get more Little White Lies

When Robert Pattison was announced as the new actor playing James Bond, all I could muster was, ​“Well, at least it’s not Callum Turner.” Unenthusiastic, mildly curious, but mostly disappointed that someone whose public and screen persona is so carved in cement had been cast in the role that’s designed for actors to emboss something new onto. But, here’s Pattinson, already a movie star with a few franchises under his belt, pairing up with the most famous director of iMac commercials, Denis Villeneuve. How thrilling. But I’m happy to be wrong. 

Back in the day I was vocally opposed to Daniel Craig when he was announced as the next 007 in October 2005. I was 11 and had only been introduced to the world of Bond maybe three or four years prior via a video game, Yet, he still seemed wrong to me. He had the face of a weathered canyon, he didn’t exude cosmopolitanism so much as he did dive bar bouncer. And, of course, those blue eyes, much too soulful. 

But, as we came to find out, all those alleged flaws came to be Craig’s secret weapons: the world weariness on his face, the melancholy in his gaze, his overt lack of sophistication and earthiness. They all became defining traits of a cycle of Bond films that, as much as they pulled from the adrenaline-pumping post‑9/​11 action of The Bourne Identity and Batman Begins, felt like a coda to a franchise that had spent nearly its entire history mourning the death of the British Empire. Craig’s cycle was more of a funeral – films for the West in decline. 

As of November 9, 2026, it seemed as if everyone and their mother had tested or been in talks to play James Bond. So it goes; the same thing happened in the mid-2000s, when names like Christian Bale and Clive Owen were in the mix, and Liam Neeson and Mel Gibson before them. That there is as much news about Jack Lowden, Callum Turner, Jack O’Connell, and even Harry Styles (LMAO) is frankly a little surprising given how, after Skyfall, interest in the franchise has seemingly dipped. Though Spectre made an excellent case for James Bond himself in the era of digital, diffuse warfare and the panopticon, Bond has been justifying his own existence since at least GoldenEye and the fall of the Berlin Wall. 

No Time to Die, after several delays and behind the scenes issues, seemed to leave little impression, even if they did kill off the character (still a shocking act, in my opinion). The new IOI video game 007 First Light has received critical and audience acclaim, but the games are themselves independent takes on the series. But I suppose, if Sherlock Holmes or Robin Hood (there was one of those that came out this year, sort of!) are any indication, if you have a good enough idea, any character, or piece of IP as the case may be, can remain immortal and withstand one reinvention after another.

Generally speaking, I don’t think audiences really know what they want from James Bond, myself included. They know what they don’t want. Few of the actors that have played him on screen have ever totally approximated Ian Fleming’s character, who Vesper Lynd describes in Casino Royale (1954) as such: ​“Bond reminds me rather of Hoagy Carmichael, but there is something cold and ruthless.” A thinly veiled avatar that allowed Fleming to fantasise about the power he wished he had been able to exert, the literary Bond is a bruiser, a mean sonofabitch, with, ​“dark, rather cruel good looks”. He’s scarred (literally, with Ш on the back of his right hand and a gash on his right cheek), angular, slim, 6’, with a long face and a mouth that can bear its teeth when need be. 

The cinematic Bonds have ebbed and flowed as to their fidelity towards this description or the character’s temperament in the book (racism, sexism, abuse, happy trigger finger, etc.), and the throughline from Connery to Craig has ultimately always been kind of tenuous. Connery was a truck driver and body builder, Lazenby was a pencil model, Moore was a TV actor, Dalton was a Royal Shakespeare Company alum, Brosnan another TV actor, and Craig another stage guy and art house film regular. The cinematic Bond has always been, whether out of circumstance or intention, a little bit chimeric. 

But they all looked good in a tux and, in the best of times, could wield the same kind of ferocity of a superhero gone rogue, while wavering on his faith for Her Majesty just enough to go off the radar one moment (Licence to Kill, Skyfall, etc.) and then come running back when M calls the next. They have a tortured relationship to duty itself: it is the thing that gives the Bond character meaning and also that which destroys him. He is constantly torn between his awareness that he is a blunt instrument of the nation and an individual without much of a soul left; it’s an uncanny analogy for the actor playing him.

The actors that were selected for the role carved Bond the cinematic figure as something both separate and, like the films themselves, somewhat reactive to the culture and cinematic landscape they inhabited. A dashing hero for an anxious Sixties (to stand in sharp relief to the mod-era), a slapstick clown for a disillusioned Seventies (to contrast against the Watergate paranoia), a debonair blank slate for the deadpan Nineties (to compete with the macho James Cameron acolytes), and so on. You don’t get Moonraker without Star Wars, or Live and Let Die without Shaft, or GoldenEye without True Lies. You know the drill. 

Really, besides the tuxedo thing, one of the only consistent trademarks of Bond is that no movie star has played him. Nor should one, hence my own initial resistance towards Pattinson. If there’s one thing that’s my number one criteria for the new Bond it’s this: James Bond cannot be played by a movie star. James Bond makes a movie star out of the man. He’s an actor whose identity then becomes synonymous with Bond, not the other way around. He is a canvas onto which the audience can project their fantasies about sophistication, class, masculinity, sex, power, geopolitical intrigue and stardom itself. Bond occupies the slightly liminal space of both megastardom and anonymity: he walks into a room and commands the attention of the villain, while moving swiftly through crowds like a well-heeled tourist. 

As Bond is a vessel for post-Cold War (or post-Empire) neuroses, so too must the actor be a vessel for Bond’s talents and hangups, their idiosyncrasies lending a reading to and interpretation of Bond while also crucially being able to pull off Bond’s ability to manipulate his visibility in any given room or space. He can make himself known at the baccarat table or disappear into the crowd during a Carnivale celebration in Rio. That’s only possible when the actor playing him doesn’t have an existing star persona overwhelming the role. (My personal picks? Daniel Kaluuya, Jamie Bell or Tom Francis.) But Bond’s body offers a vessel for the actor to then become a star: the ways in which the actor makes his 007 unique then provides a structure for him to either deepen or deviate from when the actor goes on to other roles (Brosnan’s steely hit man in The Matador; Dalton doing Moore in Looney Toons: Back in Action). 

Ultimately, who we want/don’t want as Bond is heavily predicated on where an audience’s nostalgia resides. And that’s not only for a particular Bond actor, but the way that the films were situated within a broader pop cultural landscape and how Bond himself does and does not stand apart from those en vogue archetypes. Have we graduated from the era of Nolan-esque funereal deconstructions of superhero mythos and returned to a time of stunt maximalism, à la John Wick or even The Fall Guy? With Denis Villeneuve at the helm, will it just be another piece of stately brutalism and staring-down-the-barrel contests? With Nineties back on trend, will the next Bond embody that kind of semi-naïve urbanity? 

Now that Pattinson has been cast, audiences will have no choice but to bring their knowledge and baggage of Pattinson’s career and stylistic tics to a 60-plus year old character and franchise. Rather than a blank slate onto which we can project, he’s the weird little guy, the twitchy Chris Hansen, pale pale vampire, quirky Cronenberg collaborator, etc. (I echo others’ thoughts in believing Pattinson would make a great Bond villain.) He has a panoply of characters that everyone knows, unusual for a Bond actor, and thus shaping the audience’s ability to imagine Bond as an every man who ascended into superstar secret agent almost by sheer force of will.

The announcement doesn’t matter. No one will be happy with the day of the press conference and naysayers will be the loudest section of the choir. I might be among them. But this might be a good thing. The best any Bond actor has ever done is used Bond as a way to prove themselves not just as journeyman but as capable of taking whatever bizarre, unique qualities they have as a performer and sublimating them into Bond himself, using those idiosyncrasies as a kind of authorship: Connery’s disaffectedness, Moore’s physicality, Dalton’s stately malevolence, Brosnan’s menswear readiness, Craig’s miserablism. 

Whatever those supposedly deficient qualities (frankly, my main complaint about most of the recent contenders is that they are both too famous and also too boring, although I am mostly talking about Callum Turner), hopefully the winner transforms those preconceptions into a framework through which to approach Bond. The only thing that will really have weight will be when whoever is announced actually slips on the jacket, puts the keys in the ignition of his Aston Martin, and introduces himself on screen with a smirk, a drink order, a bullet to the head, and his name. Only then will we know if our new Bond deserves his license after all. 




Source link

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *